The Duty of Witness in an Age of Secrecy

By Dr Paul Alexander Wolf

There are times in history when governments forget that secrecy was meant to protect the people, not to protect power. This is one of them.

In Gaza, the trucks wait at closed borders while leaders trade threats. Food is withheld in the name of security; the starving are told to wait for diplomacy. Each side blames the other, yet the result is the same: civilians pay with their lives while politicians posture before cameras.

It is tempting to call this politics. It is not. It is moral bankruptcy disguised as governance.

The Hidden Arithmetic of Power

We live in a world where the most dangerous decisions are made behind classified doors. The public is told only what suits the moment.

When the towers fell in 2001, the grief of a nation became a passport for endless war. Iraq was invaded on a lie, Afghanistan on inertia, and still the architects of those failures walk free.

In Israel, a prime minister indicted for corruption still commands the machinery of war, invoking self-defence to justify collective punishment. Within days of a ceasefire, aid was halved again.

From Washington to Tel Aviv, from Moscow to Beijing, the pattern repeats: fear becomes currency, secrecy becomes policy, and truth becomes collateral.

The Excuse of Security

Every empire, democratic or not, learns the same language of concealment. It begins with national security and ends with moral impunity.

In Germany, obedience masked atrocity. In the United States, surveillance expanded until privacy became quaint. In Israel, occupation has become habit, and war a reflex.

When governments act as if survival excuses everything, they cross the line that separates civilisation from survivalism. They forget that security without justice is just control by another name.

The Vanishing of Accountability

We know the names. Epstein’s networks buried. Netanyahu’s indictments stalled. Archives on political assassinations still sealed decades after the fact.

When the truth is inconvenient, it is postponed. When questions grow dangerous, they are classified. And the public, exhausted by crisis, learns to stop asking.

Yet the cost of silence is cumulative. Each unchallenged lie becomes a precedent. Each hidden file becomes a permission slip for the next abuse.

The Power of Ordinary Witness

No individual can end a war. But silence, multiplied by millions, sustains it.

We may not hold office, but we hold evidence. We can document, share, verify, and refuse to look away. Journalists like Saleh Aljafarawi gave their lives for that duty. Doctors, aid workers, and teachers in Gaza continue it every day, even when hospitals burn and the world scrolls past.

Their courage is a mirror held up to the rest of us. It asks whether comfort has made us complicit.

What Truth Still Demands

The task before us is not only to condemn but to connect – to draw the line from hidden crimes to public consequence.

The ICC and ICJ have already named war crimes in Gaza. The evidence exists; what is missing is enforcement. Until citizens insist that law apply to allies as well as enemies, the law remains theatre.

Transparency is not treason. It is the lifeblood of democracy.

Accountability is not vengeance. It is the oxygen of justice.

Every citizen has the right – and the duty -to ask uncomfortable questions, even when governments prefer applause.

The Measure of a Nation

The measure of a nation is not the strength of its military but the honesty of its memory.

The measure of leadership is not how many enemies it defeats but how many truths it can face.

When leaders hide their failures behind flags, they turn patriotism into camouflage. When citizens accept that camouflage, they surrender the very freedom they claim to defend.

We must learn again the courage of scrutiny – the insistence that secrecy serves only when it protects life, not when it conceals its destruction.

The Covenant of Conscience

We are not powerless. Each of us can be a keeper of record, a carrier of light.

We can demand that aid reach the hungry, that journalists work without fear, that law is not suspended for convenience.

Let it be said of our generation that we refused to inherit the lies of our leaders.

Let it be said that when secrecy became the language of state, citizens answered with truth.

The world will not be rebuilt by governments alone. It will be rebuilt by those who still believe that conscience is a form of power.

Because when truth becomes dangerous, to speak is to act.

And when silence becomes normal, to care is revolutionary.

>>>>>

Author’s Note

Dr Paul Alexander Wolf is an Australian physician and humanitarian writer. He has served in both domestic and 🏥 resource-limited settings overseas, and writes on conscience, conflict, and the moral responsibilities of leadership.